Unskilled and Unaware

Have you ever met someone who is unskilled, yet completely confident?

Not faking it. He is genuinely sure he’s right. Psychology has a name for this.

In 1999, two psychologists at Cornell, Justin Kruger and David Dunning, set out to test it. They gave students tests in three areas, humour, logic and grammar, and then asked them one question: where do you think you rank among your peers?

TestWhere the weakest group actually rankedWhere they thought they ranked
Humour12th percentile58th percentile
Logic12th percentile68th percentile
Grammar10th percentile67th percentile

The people at the very bottom believed they were above average.

In another logic test of 10 questions, the weakest group got 0.3 answers right on average. They thought they had got 5.5.

Why does this happen?

The skill you need to do something well is the same skill you need to judge it. If you don’t know the rules of grammar, you can’t write a correct sentence, and you also can’t see that your sentence is wrong. So weak performers carry a double burden: they make mistakes, and they can’t see that they made them.

Two explanations: can’t see, or won’t see?

Can’t see. Kruger and Dunning’s explanation: weak performers simply lack the skill to notice their own mistakes.

Won’t see. In 2015, a team of researchers (Kim, Chiu and Bregant) ran a clever experiment. Students all took the same visual puzzle test. After they finished, and before they rated themselves, they were split into two groups:

  • The first group was told the test measured “visual ability”, which matters equally to men and women.
  • The second group was told it measured “language ability”, and that this ability matters in areas usually linked to women, like relationships, communication and teaching.

Same test, same answers. The only thing that changed was how much the test mattered to each person.

In the first group, men and women both overrated themselves as usual. In the second group, something interesting happened:

  • The men felt the test wasn’t about them, so they had nothing to defend, and they rated themselves almost exactly right.
  • The women felt the test touched how they saw themselves, so they overrated: 21 of 24 said they were average or above, whatever their real scores.

In other words: when a test doesn’t touch your self-image, you see yourself clearly. When it does, you look away.

Their conclusion: weak performers can sometimes sense their weakness, but they look away when the skill matters to their ego.

It’s probably both. And either way, the result is the same: they never see a reason to improve.

When you can’t judge the argument, you judge the person

I know someone like this. Unskilled, and very sure of himself. But I noticed something interesting: when someone he admires tells him he’s wrong, he accepts it. When anyone else tells him, he doesn’t move.

The research helps explain why. In one of the studies, the researchers asked the weakest and strongest participants to grade other people’s tests. The weak group was much worse at telling good work from bad. And after seeing better answers than their own, they didn’t change how they saw themselves at all.

So when an equal disagrees with him, he can’t tell whose argument is stronger. To him, both sound the same, so he keeps his own. When someone he admires says it, he skips judging the argument completely. He trusts the person instead.

Respect becomes a shortcut that replaces the skill he’s missing.

The paper quotes psychologist Richard Nisbett on his colleague Amos Tversky: “The quicker you realize that Amos is smarter than you, the smarter you yourself must be.” Recognising someone better than you is itself a skill.

The paradox: the cure is skill

In the fourth study, half of the participants got a short training session, about 10 minutes, on how to solve the logic puzzle they had just taken. The other half did an unrelated task.

Before the training, the weakest group thought they had solved about 5 of 10 problems. After it, they said about 1, close to the truth. The untrained group didn’t change at all.

Nobody told them they were wrong. They learned the correct way, looked back at their own answers, and saw the mistakes themselves.

The only thing that made them see they were bad was becoming a little better.

Why teaching works where criticism fails

Criticise someone, and their ego feels attacked. They defend themselves and ignore the weakness.

Teach them instead, and there is no attack, so there is nothing to defend. The knowledge comes in indirectly, they spot the mistake on their own, and they accept it.

Something you discover yourself is far easier to accept than something you’re told.

My take: let them own the idea

From what I’ve seen, these people don’t want to be taught anything. They want to stay smart, respected, and better than you think they are. So when you tell them something, they make it feel as if they discovered it.

That’s fine. If the goal is for them to improve, it matters more that they own the idea than that you get the credit.

The flip side: the strong underrate themselves

In every study, the top performers scored around the 86th to 90th percentile but placed themselves around the 70s.

They weren’t wrong about their own work. They guessed their raw scores well. Their mistake was about other people: the test felt easy to them, so they assumed it was easy for everyone. Once they graded other people’s tests and saw how most people did, they raised their estimate.

The weak misjudge themselves. The strong misjudge everyone else.

Takeaways

  1. Confidence isn’t proof of skill.
  2. Build the skill first, and let people discover their own mistakes.
  3. Lower the stakes of feedback. Make it about the work, not the person.
  4. Choose the messenger. Some people listen to who says it, not what’s said.

As Charles Darwin wrote: “Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.”

Sources

  • Kruger, J. & Dunning, D. (1999). Unskilled and Unaware of It. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6), 1121–1134.
  • Kim, Y.-H., Chiu, C.-Y. & Bregant, J. (2015). Unskilled and Don’t Want to Be Aware of It. PLOS ONE, 10(6).